Dr Sarah Taber Profile picture
Jun 3, 2018 25 tweets 5 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
wow someone got really offended about @jbouie's tweets from earlier today but is too scared to tag him



with some assist from historian twitter let's get into it #twitterstorian
The bit that seems to bog folks down is "but ppl hated each other before the Enlightenment, therefore racism must have already existed."

This is a misreading of history. But before we get into the details, let's talk WHY this particular misreading of history. Who does it serve?
There are people whose political & career ambitions depend on racial conflict.

They need it to thrive.

So they need people to believe that racial conflict is natural. Inevitable. Primordial.
And they need folks to believe that a functioning multiracial society is an aberration of the modern age. Unnatural. Untested. Unknown. Impossible.
When you see a "thought leader" who insists multiculturalism is impossible- when there are millennia of societies across the world that show us otherwise-

know that they're not just ignorant of history. They're incompetent & scared of having to compete in a full world.
They know that in order for anyone to care what they have to say, they have to divide & conquer and appeal to the basest fears of people who don't know any better. That's the highest goal they can imagine for themselves.

Sad!
Now that that's out of the way. As far as we know, yes, humans have always had group-on-group rivalries.

Literally nobody says "group-on-group rivalries & judgments didn't exist before the Enlightenment."
What the Enlightenment did was drastically change how the lines of "in our group, not in our group" were drawn

In Europe just prior to the Enlightenment, there were national rivalries. But the big line was drawn by religion. Including whether or not it was ok to enslave someone.
Crudely, if someone was a Christian, they were a real child of God & shouldn't be enslaved. If not, go for it.

But that rule had a big problem. Enslaved Africans figured this out & kept getting baptized so they could stop being slaves.
Well THAT nonsense just had to stop. How are you supposed to run a sugar plantation if everyone keeps finding Jesus?

So, colonial societies in Europe found themselves on the market for a new dividing line between who was OK to enslave and who wasn't.
By this time, colonizers in the New World had already figured out that buying Africans was a better investment than indentured servants from Europe, or trying to enslave Native Americans.
Native Americans kept dying from imported diseases, if they didn't run away first (which was p. easy for them to do since they knew the terrain & had friends & family to go to)

and indentured servants had this annoying habit of earning their freedom after several years.
So after that trial & error, colonial Europe built solid trade routes, coastal forts, specialized ships, invented in the concept of "insurance," etc so as to capture & traffic millions of Africans to America.
The result was that European colonizers were surrounded by hundreds, thousands of Africans toiling away and not looking very happy about it.

Humans are funny. We have this thing called empathy. We have to find ways to turn it off.
Have you ever worked as a slave overseer? I have.

I mean, they called it "supervising inmate farm crews," but that's semantics.
Supervising prisoners with jobs (thanks, @TaikaWaititi) does interesting things to your mind, & it does them quickly.

Intellectually you know the inmates are all just kids who got caught with 1oz of weed, bc violent criminals & serious felons don't get farm privileges.
Intellectually you know since they don't get paid & can't get a reference out of this job, literally what's the point for them of trying hard. "Giving it your best" is not how slave labor works.

Which, as the person who's tasked with supervising them, is just kinda difficult.
They gave you this shitty inmate crew, it's so hot you've got tunnel vision, and they're just faffing around, and that's not ok bc there's this whole list of things you have to get done before the end of the day.
Plus there's the whole Stanford Prison Experiment angle of the thing where putting a bunch of guys in prison jumpsuits and putting someone else in charge of them just ... really sets the tone for the whole dynamic. Y'know?
There was this whole dynamic put into play where the people in jumpsuits became a problem you had to manage. There were certain feelings that came up when you saw an inmate in uniform, regardless of whether they were on your crew or not.
At that time @RobTaber was deep in his work on the Haitian Revolution, and we talked a lot about the role of poor white overseers in building modern racism.
In other words, I knew exactly what was happening in my head. And it still kept going. The nature of the job trains your brain to respond to people in jumpsuits as something a little different or less than human.
There's a reason every society we have record of has had very clear rules about physical appearance of slaves & second-class citizens.
There's a reason ancient Sumer gave slaves visible brand marks, Germany made Jewish people wear gold stars, and today we make inmates wear the orange pajamas.
For slavery and second-class status to work, every person has to instantly be on the same page about who's on the bottom of the social pyramid and can be, nay, MUST be treated as less than human.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dr Sarah Taber

Dr Sarah Taber Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SarahTaber_bww

Oct 9, 2018
Fun fact you learn after working in ag for a while: family farms run by a man who's really into conservatism, rape culture, racism, and hating women are *the most likely to fail.*
There appear to be lots of reasons for this.

#1, running any business takes a basic level of empathy. You have to put yourself in customer's shoes enough to figure out what they want & give it to them.

Rape culture & racism teach you how to NOT put yourself in ppl's shoes.
#2, to run a business successfully you also have to be able to put yourself in your employees', contractors', etc shoes to figure out how to engage them successfully to get the result you want.

Again: hard to do that when your mentality is shaped by ... hating other people.
Read 11 tweets
Oct 8, 2018
This is interesting. This account fairly likely to be a bot- number salad after the name, interactions w other bot accounts, & a 50/50 mix of folksy farm observations & Russian talking points.
Usually when I post on political topics, it draws some bot fire. Brett Kavanaugh & removal of UNC's confederate memorial got especially botty.
But for those of you who remember the Great Tractor-Turning Incident- that was a post that got a lot of angry responses from real live humans.

Responses from real live angry humans are very different from bots.
Read 10 tweets
Oct 7, 2018
You guys I want to tell you the story of a #Resistance wedding.

No pics of the wedding itself bc of reasons that will soon become clear, so lemme paint you a picture.
Bride & groom both heavily involved in Indivisible, and there's an election in a month. So they went with a straightforward courthouse wedding.
Except it turns out courthouse weddings in Fayetteville are actually kind of complicated

1) lots of bureaucratic red tape

2) they're not in the courthouse. The magistrate who handles marriages is INSIDE THE COUNTY JAIL
Read 10 tweets
Oct 6, 2018
A buddy was handing out some apples he got from a little farm stand up in the mountains.

These local farm-fresh apples were uhhhhh coated in fungicide.
They had a light powdery coating, which *can* be innocuous- often it's just dust from the field, or an inert clay like Surround (works as a sunscreen to keep apples from getting sun scald on the tree, and repels bugs too).
But! Not in this case. Right out of the bag they had that really juicy fresh apple smell, but as soon as that wore off there was that garlicky metallic "pesticide storage shed" smell that ag folks know & love.

Also featured a garlicky metallic pesticide aftertaste. 🙄
Read 10 tweets
Oct 5, 2018
This morning #ICalledMyReps and they wouldn't pick up.

Thom Tillis has several offices in NC.

All of their phones are shut down. There's a "we just help with hurricane Florence stuff! Stay safe!" message & no way to leave a voicemail.
Which is funny, bc they were answering their phones when I called to them last week. They weren't "shut down for a hurricane that ended weeks ago" back then.
This has nothing to do with Florence. This is a communications shutdown because they *don't want to hear from constituents.*
Read 11 tweets
Oct 2, 2018
YUP

One of the farmers straight-up told @RyanLizza "if they were legal we'd have to pay them more."

If you're confused on why farmers keep voting for bad immigration policy (even though they swear they "don't agree,") that's it right there.
To your face they'll say oh, it's just so terrible that ICE is doing raids!

But if it weren't for threat of deportation, farmworkers would actually be able to fight for higher pay.

Deep down, farmers know this. If you watch what they DO, instead of what they say, that's clear.
They know their biz model can't survive w/o threat of deportation. So instead of fixing their biz model, they vote for ICE raids.

Then they cringe and fuss about how dreadful it all is.

They can't even sack up to be proper bastards about it. It's chickenshit all the way down.
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(