Simon Cox Profile picture
Jun 28, 2018 15 tweets 4 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
EU Court’s Adv-Gen opinion on #Poland #FairTrial case is out. Thread to follow…
Irish High Court was asked by Polish Gov to extradite Mr Celmer under EU law for trial on drug charges. Irish judge ruled Poland’s Gov has seriously undermined rule of law by taking political control over judges (agreeing with Euro Commission) 2/
So Irish Court asked Court of Justice of EU to rule on # approach Irish Court should take. AG opinion is advice to CJEU on how CJEU should rule. Mostly CJEU takes that advice, but not always. 3/
CJEU has already ruled that national court can block extradition to another EU state if prison conditions would be inhuman/degrading. 4/
This is first CJEU case about challenge to EU extradition on fair trial grounds*. AG says national court can block extradition. No surprise - big Q is “what approach should Court take to deciding this” 5/
A-G says the decision remains for Irish court. It’s not for the CJEU to rule *on the facts*. And the Irish court has power even though the Council has not decided whether to agree with Commission on RoL in Poland. 6/
A-G says (39-45) Irish court’s task (risk to individual of no fair trial) is v different from the EU tasks (serious perisistent breach of RoL by Poland) 7/
A-G says (72) real risk of denial of fair trial *isnt enough* to block extradition. Must be real risk of *flagrant* denial of fair trial. 8/
A-G says (90) lack of judicial independence *can* give rise to real risk of flagrant denial of fair trial. Points out only in Al-Nashiri v Poland (@OSFJustice case btw) that European Court of Human Rights found this 9/
Celmer argued that, where Irish Court concludes Poland’s #RuleOfLaw has broken down in general, there is no second stage of assessing specific risk to Celmer. A-G says (104) Court should reject this 10/
A-G says Irish Court can only block extradition if the general risk of flagrant denial of fair trial is shown to apply to Celmer’s facts. He adopts Commission’s examples 11/
A-G also says Irish Court *must* ask Polish Gov for info on whether Celmer would get a fair trial. 12/
Celmer wanted to defeat extradition without any evidence specific to him. That plan is dead - if CJEU agrees with A-G.

But it doesn’t mean Celmer’s case is over... 13/
Instead, Irish Court can ask Poland to explain which judges might hear his case (on trial and on any appeal), who appointed them - and what guarantees there are against political interference. 14/
Celmer’s “blanket” argument may have blocked all extraditions to Poland. But the A-G’s approach may see courts across EU quizzing PL Gov abt its judiciary & their independence. Watch that space. 15/15

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Simon Cox

Simon Cox Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SimonFRCox

Oct 4, 2018
Areopagitica was Milton’s call for rational, evidence-based debate - to ensure Parliament acts wisely. My kinsman abuses it for nationalist rhetoric…
Areopagitica was Milton’s argument against Government censorship, at height of English civil war. It’s themes are Liberty & Truth.… >
For Milton, democracy meant an engaged public, informed & debating.… >
Read 5 tweets
Sep 18, 2018
No-deal Brexit threatens pensions & benefits of 100s of 1000s of UK & EU27 citz who aren't citizens of where they live. Thread 1/
EU law guarantees EU citz equal treatment & portability of old age pensions, child benefits & many disability benefits. UK cant discriminate against UK pension holders who live elsewhere in EU. Nor can EU27 stop pensions for their citizens in UK . 2/
EU social security "co-ordination" is one of the oldest - & greatest - legal rights in the EU. Since 1957 EU citz have known they can move around, change job and they will not be treated the worse for it. 3/
Read 14 tweets
Sep 18, 2018
UK media can’t deal with a news story where what British voters want doesn’t matter much for what they get. >
Good eg of liberal media denialism @guardian @jessicaelgot “UK can just decide to cancel A50 - but does it want to??”

No - real news is “EU probably wont even let UK do that...” >
News presentation can’t be explained by general journo reluctance to say “UK can’t decide this alone”. Guardian’s does that for climate change & more >
Read 5 tweets
Sep 13, 2018
Europe’s strong line against Orbán is a historic moment for democratic unity. Especially for conservatives. #Hungary

A celebratory thread. 1/
Orbán’s Party - Fidesz - is a long-standing member of @EPP , Europe’s main alliance of conservative parties. So is Angela Merkel’s CDU. 2/
As Orbán helmed Hungary towards menacing autocracy, the EPP just kept on paying out more rope. Emboldened, Fidesz became more outrageous. 3/
Read 10 tweets
Sep 13, 2018
Why did UK Tories oppose EU broad-based action to defend #Hungary’s democracy? Thread 1/
#Orbán’s popular - but corrupt & racist - regime was charged before Europe’s directly elected Parliament with undermining Hungary’s democracy… 2/
Conservatives across Europe joined a broad spectrum of the overwhelming majority of MEPs to demand action. (The first time these new powers have been invoked by Parliament) 3/
Read 17 tweets
Sep 13, 2018
Fascinating info from field study on #migrantworkers in #Italy ‘s farms.

In Ragusa, Romanians (new to sector) get worse wages than Tunisians (long connections, unionized)! >
Farmwork is increasingly women’s work in Italy. Asylum-seeking mothers with humanitarian permits work on farms - because having children mean employers won’t take them for domestic work.
Those fresh oranges from #Italy? The farmer got 35 cents for a kilo. Picked by Africans, Albanians, Romanians for low low wages with shitty accommodation.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!


0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy


3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!