Things which are not #transphobic, despite TRAs shouting otherwise:
- safeguarding children and vulnerable adults
- homosexuality
- heterosexuality
- women’s rights
- science
- evidence-based healthcare
- asking questions
- women saying ‘no’ to men
Sex, race, religion, sexual orientation: all are protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010. Gender identity is not. Gender reassignment is not the winning card in a game of top trumps. Every protected characteristic must be considered when changing policy or law.
Women, men, genuine sufferers of gender dysphoria: Your rights, safety, privacy and dignity and those of your children and elderly parents are under threat by a bunch of self-entitled men yelling ‘transphobe’ at you. You are allowed to say no.
- @Girlguiding say that boys and men can share overnight accommodation with your daughter without your knowledge or consent?
- @UKLabour has a male women’s officer who campaigns against ‘cis’ women?
- @cityoflondon wants to allow teenage boys to use the girls’ changing rooms in their schools if they say ‘I’m a girl’ (and presumably click their heels 3 times)?
- @hmpps women in prison are forced to shower with intact male murderers and rapists?
- @newlook@Primark@marksandspencer allow men into the ladies’ changing rooms, despite clear evidence showing a threefold rise in voyeurism and sexual assault when this happens?
- @YHAOfficial allow men into the women’s dormitories and bathrooms?
- @CaledonianSleep’s policy could put a strange man into an overnight train sleeping compartment with a woman?
- @LGAcomms members are REFUSING to recognise that sex is a protected characteristic in law?
- @stonewalluk says that lesbians fancy men and gays fancy women?
- people with gender dysphoria- aka actual, real trans people- are being told THEY are transphobic for raising concerns with gender self-ID?
- politicians at a @fawcettsociety event said that a parliament made up of 50% men and 50% transwomen (male-born) would be representative?
Cos I don’t. None of those things are remotely ok, or fair, or progressive, or kind, or anything else good.
Gender self-ID is a misogynistic, homophobic, anti-safeguarding policy that should never have been written into policy, let alone law.
We at #ManFriday will continue to put ourselves out there to say no. You can say it too. Find your voice. Find the way you want to use it. ❤️
NO!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
My thoughts on why @Girlguiding’s transgender inclusion policy is so dangerous for girls and trans-excluding rather than trans-including:
1) 97% of sexual crimes are committed by men and boys. Allowing boys to share overnight accommodation, showers and changing facilities with girls and allowing men to provide overnight and intimate care for girls puts those girls in danger.
2) This is especially dangerous because @Girlguiding have made it clear that anyone expressing concerns about safeguarding where those concerns touch on trans is in danger of being expelled from the organisation. The duty to report concerns has been compromised.
3: Ask a properly-educated friend how to pronounce ‘hyperbole’. Practice until you can say it correctly and fluently. Then one can pass for ‘one of us’ in social situations.
I was troubled at @EmilyThornberry’s remark at a recent @Fabians event that ‘women have space to budge up for transwomen in our spaces’ in response to my question about @UKLabour allowing self-ID women on their AWS. It came after a great speech in which Thornberry (1)
spoke at length about the male domination of politics and female MPs fighting to be both seen and heard against a tidal wave of abuse. I was amazed that she contradicted herself like that. Women don’t have room to ‘budge up’. (2)
Women are under-represented across leadership positions in politics, business, public and social life. That’s WHY we have programs to attract and advance women. That’s WHY we have women-only spaces. Men must do the budging and make the space, not women. (3)
To the doxxers of #ManFriday... When you go on holiday, may you always get food poisoning, delayed flights, the seat next to the toddler and lost baggage.
Following @DebbieHayton 's call for suggestions on how to balance women's rights, safety, privacy and dignity with the privacy desired by sufferers of gender dysphoria, I'm interested to know what people think of my proposal. See thread...
My proposal: keep the GRA as it is. Make the process for obtaining a GRC completely transparent, with clear, published criteria for obtaining one and a review meeting with the board 1 year into the 2 year ‘living as’ period. (1)
No changes to sex on legal ID documents without a GRC / re-issued birth certificate. This covers passports and driving licences. (2)
Long, long thread. A re-write of @LadybirdBooks Sleeping Beauty to make it fit for the 21st Century:
Once upon a time, there lived a kign and queen wo were very happy, except for one thing. They both longed to have children but they had none. (1)
Now it happened one day, when the queen had been bathing, that a frog crept out of the water. The queen told the frog all about her longing for a child and felt much better. (2)
Later that year, she found out that she was expecting a baby. She and her husband were delighted. (3)