This article about the profound influence of Virginia economist James McGill Buchanan (an intellectual descendant of John C. Calhoun) on ascendant American oligarchy is chilling. We’re already quite far down this destructive path.
Buchanan’s extremely, self-servingly dark view of human nature, which “justified” his rejection of any search for the public good through politics, is a hallmark of authoritarianism. This is why Christian nationalism and oligarchy dovetail so comfortably.
Advocates for utopias, which in attempts at implementation always trend to authoritarianism, share a rejection of politics, a desire to be free from politics, even from freedom as most understand it. Libertarianism and theocracy are conservative utopias. #EmptyThePews#Resist
Of course, utopian ideology occurs on the Left and the Right. Key to utopian thinking is the rejection democratic politics in pursuit of the common good. This is what Buchanan, who defined politics as the public pursuit of naked self-interest, pushed, and what Reagan mainstreamed
In other words, the erosion of belief in democracy itself has occurred in America most prominently on the Right through Reaganite rhetoric defining government as the problem rather than solution. In theocratic speak, the rhetoric is of making the state or welfare into an idol.
For more on the weaponizing of theocratic/Christian nationalist rhetoric of idolatry against social welfare, see this thread:
Of course, non-partisan research has long since pointed us to the asymmetric nature of American polarization, coming primarily from the Right. Even the ever civil and “centrist” to a (frankly glaring) fault @TheAtlantic has to admit it:
This is why the influence campaigns of Putinist Russia, an authoritarian state that seeks to undermine democracy, rule of law, and human rights globally, are most successful in the US on the Right. The affinity of Western conservatives for Christian Russians has a long history.
My published academic and policy research goes some way toward unpacking that history. If you want to do a deeper dive, here are some policy long reads you can start with:
Putin’s Russia has been successfully claiming the mantle of international leadership in the aggressive pursuit of “traditional values” for some time. Theocracy and kleptocracy often go hand-in-hand, and America too is becoming “one kleptocracy under God”:
If you learn and benefit from threads like these and can afford to do so, please consider funding my work via Patreon at the $5 level or more. If you can’t afford to, please don’t pledge. It’s not like I’m a church 😈
1. I just sent out this month's newsletter for all @Patreon patrons who support me with a $5 or higher monthly pledge. If you find my work valuable and would like the inside Stroop scoop, please consider joining them!
2. At the end of the last academic year, I faced a choice--move back in with my parents in Indiana to pursue the freelance writing and speaking opportunities I was getting more of, or adjunct at the University of South Florida for low pay and no benefits. Or find something new.
3. Here's a thread with some of my life story up to the present. The travel to Austria next spring to do a semester of research mentioned in it fell through despite me having been promised it for years.
Another reversal of an improvement for LGBTQ acceptance in an evangelical institution (World Vision is the other one I have in mind). Evangelicalism doesn’t change its patriarchal ways. It just casts out the people who would make it better.
I also RT requests for financial help fairly often. Unfortunately, many in the #Exvangelical community have needs and are hampered by lack of education, meaningless degrees, or lack of professional experience outside evangelical institutions. The social costs of leaving are high.
I don’t want or expect anyone who can’t afford it to give, and I don’t want anyone to feel obligated; even just RTing those requests is immensely helpful. It is my hope that someday we’ll have some kind of foundation to fund #Exvangelical projects and meet needs. #EmptyThePews
Sometimes crowdfunding is all that stands between an #Exvangelical and homelessness, or being forced to return to a toxic, abusive living situation. That’s the uncomfortable reality. I do make small donations myself to almost every fundraising request I amplify.
September is a big month! I’m at the airport on my way Florida for The #Exvangelical Community: Paths, Projects, Prospects. In the last two days I’ve filed two pieces with editors, and this week I did podcasts w/ @NiceMangos and @kitchencultpod (@haettinger and @mxdarkwater). #FF
Next weekend I’ll be in Charleston, South Carolina to give a talk for @CHShumanists, and am very much looking forward to that! October is also pretty full!
1. A few thoughts on Trump's dinner in honor of evangelicals, which I'll be discussing with @RickSmithShow later. Key context to consider is that fascism is concerned with defining who belongs to "the nation" or "the people," and who doesn't. Internal enemies (Others) are needed.
2. This dovetails neatly with the way in which fundamentalist believers police who does and does not count as a member of their religious confession. This is critical to understanding the Christian Right's politics of "religious freedom":
3. Indeed, as I have written elsewhere, "Fundamentalism is authoritarianism in microcosm, or on the margins. Fascism is essentially fundamentalism in power." The vast majority of white evangelicals are authoritarian and fundamentalist.