The framing of @paularogo's @Essence piece on Cynthia Erivo is…interesting.
This response will be a long thread bc it's impt that:
◾️we step back to analyze the larger narrative that's being created ◾️Essence is aware that we're aware of deliberate editorial decisions.
And to expand on point about potential context: She might've even looked into the data or done a quick tally herself of prestige dramas (particularly historic fiction) to see what the breakdown is of non-African American Blacks portraying African-Americans over the last 10 yrs
…And the market parallels of Euro & Aussie actors taking advantage of US opportunity.
She might've even looked into the existing research to contextualize Cynthia's allusion to lack of opportunity for Black Brit women…
(Spoiler alert: Erasure of Black women in favor of mixed/biracial is very real in the UK and even more advanced than what's going on here.)
So if you got your plate of food stolen by someone else, I should let you come eat off mine, no questions? The plate of food that took 359 yrs of fixin' (lineage)? When all I have is my plate?
And smile and nod while you spit the bones in my direction?
Mmmmhmm. Okay.
I can empathize without self-sacrificing on the altar of sometime-y, convenient, generic Blackness.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Here is why Cynthia Erivo, in particular, should not play Harriet Tubman.
TL; DR: There’s a troubling pattern of Cynthia repeatedly, deliberately, selectively *choosing* to not give respect to African-American heritage – the heritage of Harriet Tubman. #HarrietDeservesBetter
Note: There’s an argument to be made against Africans/non-DOS Brits playing important African-American figures – & vice versa. Performance & perspective, where & how we take up space, larger economic & cultural issues at play.
Others have unpacked that; this thread won’t.
This thread is about why Cynthia Erivo should not play Harriet Tubman, “the Moses of her people” & a sacred African-American ancestor. It goes beyond Cynthia’s birthplace, accent, heritage & even her association with an ethnic bigot.