1/ On Tuesday, Roger Stone was interviewed by Chuck Todd. One segment is included above. What follows is a partial nonverbal analysis of a particularly telling behavior pattern exhibited by Mr. Stone.
2/ Chuck Todd (beginning at 0:00): "Did, um, you suggest to the PRESIDENT that he [stutter] at that press conference say, 'Russia, if you're listening - ahum, GO FIND HILLARY CLINTON'S EMAILS'?"
3/ Roger Stone: "I CAN HONESTLY SAY THAT AH, THAT CANDIDATE TRUMP, Donald Trump, President Trump and I have NEVER DISCUSSED the Wikileaks disclosures before, during, or after [stutter] -"
4/ Chuck Todd: "[over-talking] You never had a single discussion about Hillary Clinton emails, ah, with him at all?"
Roger Stone: "THAT IS CORRECT."
5/ Chuck Todd: "Nothing about Hillary Clinton [slurring] I understand Wikileaks - Not once about Hillary Clinton emails - You never had one conversation with President Trump ABOUT THAT?"
6/ Roger Stone: "Not, not a single one - NO. ABSOLUTELY NOT."
Chuck Todd: "[over-talking] And that's the same answer you're going to give if Mr. Mueller asks you that question?"
7/ Roger Stone: "IT'S THE SAME answer THAT I GAVE the HOUSE INTELLigence Committee under oath, ah, months ago - it's certainly the same answer I WOULD give the SPECIAL COUNSEL [stutter] ah, ah, Donald Trump and I - have never discussed the matter."
8/ Note that Mr. Stone blinks very frequently during this entire 47-second video. An increased frequency of blinking (above baseline) is a nonspecific, but highly reliable, indicator of anxiety.
9/ Yet there's more nuance revealed here. Go back and watch the video once again. Notice also, that some (12) of Roger Stone's blinking is of incredibly long duration.
10/ Most of these extended blinks are either simultaneous with his verbal denials - or a split second after Chuck Todd asks him a particularly crucial question or uses a keyword. These moments of Roger Stone's extended blinking are written in the above dialog in ALL CAPS.
11/ It's possible, perhaps, that Mr. Stone has an ophthalmic condition which causes him to blink more often (e.g. Dry Eye Syndrome). However, if this is true, it still doesn't account for the timing of his extended blinking - ...
12/ ... once again, highly coincident with his denials and/or with Mr. Todd's evocative words/questions.
13/ Thin-slicing his blinking even further - when two adjacent tissues are moving in opposite directions - particularly as part of a facial expression - it sends up a tremendous red flag.
14/ Note the image immediately above - Roger Stone's forehead muscles are contracted and vectored upward - whereas his eyelids are in the midst of an extended blink.
15/ This opposite-direction dynamic is unnatural and is a profound nonverbal analog of, "The gentleman doth protests too much, methinks (apologies to William Shakespeare)."
16/ There are some interesting paralanguage/statement analysis tells here as well. Whenever someone says, "I can honestly say" - with high probability - they're lying.
17/ Additionally, Mr. Stone's use of "That is correct" - is a non-contraction (e.g., as opposed to "That's correct").
18/ In the act of telling a lie (here, a false affirmation), people will have a strong tendency to use non-contractions. But when the same person speaks the truth, they'll tend to use contractions.
19/ SUMMARY: Roger Stone's cluster of nonverbal, verbal, and paralanguage behaviors exhibited in this video is highly consistent with multiple examples of deceptions.
END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2/ Donald Trump delivered a campaign speech earlier today in Oshkosh, Wisconsin. He repeatedly made the expression show in this accompanying still image. Note his central forehead is contracted and elevated while simultaneously displaying a (feigned) mouth smile.
3/ We all make an expression similar to this one *once-in-a-while* when we're feeling:
• Smug Incredulity
• Arrogance
• Contempt
(although all of these thought-emotions have other facial expressions with which they're associated)
1/ Yesterday, after the closest Senate vote in 137 years, Brett Kavanaugh was confirmed as an Associate Justice on the United States Supreme Court. Ashley Kavanaugh's body language during her husband's swearing-in ceremony is worthy of scrutiny.
2/ Note in the above image, as retired Justice Anthony Kennedy administers the Judicial Oath to Brett Kavanaugh, Ashley Kavanaugh is standing with her left leg crossed in front of her right leg. This nonverbal display indicates a lowered confidence level & a beta emotional tone.
1/ There are many nonverbal signs indicating relative levels of confidence. During last week's hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee, Brett Kavanaugh and Christine Blasey Ford exhibited contrasting examples of one such signal.
2/ When a person raises their right hand to be sworn-in before testifying, if their fingers and/or thumb are spread apart - it signals low levels of confidence.
1/ The following is my second analysis of a portion of Brett Kavanaugh's testimony during his hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee on 27 September 2018.
2/ JOHN KENNEDY (beginning at 3:45:39): "I’m — I’m sorry, judge, for what you and your family have been through. And I’m sorry - for what Dr. Ford and her family have been through. It could have been avoided [long pause] Do you believe in God?"
1/ In case you hadn't heard, on Wednesday 27 September 2018, both Brett Kavanaugh and Christine Blasey Ford testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee.
2/ This hearing could supply a year's worth of nonverbal teaching examples and it would close to impossible to analyze the entire event in one session. Thus, what follows is the first of several analyses of this historic exchange.