2. In memo to Commerce Sec Wilbur Ross, Census Bureau Acting Dir. Ron Jarmin, other officials write adding citizenship Q “is very costly, harms the quality of the census count, & would use substantially less accurate citizenship status data than are available” from other agencies
3. To get citizenship estimates for #2020census, Census Bureau has been trying to get access to massive gov’t datasets -- Social Security Administration records, visa/passport data from State Dept & naturalization data from USCIS, according to draft bureau document
4. In 7/21/2017 email, Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach says “at the direction of Steve Bannon” he spoke with Commerce Sec. Wilbur Ross about lack of citizenship question on census “a few months” before writing to Ross’s chief of staff, Wendy Teramoto
5. In 7/14/2017 email to Commerce Sec. Wilbur Ross, Kris Kobach writes it’s a “problem” that “aliens who do not actually ‘reside’” in US are counted for congressional reapportionment, and he proposes wording for citizenship question that asks noncitizens about immigration status
6. REMINDER: Justice Dept sent Census Bureau letter in Dec 2017 requesting citizenship Q to better enforce Voting Rights Act. Acting head of DOJ civil rights division, John Gore, testified in Congress in May that he had no contact w Kobach abt DOJ request:
7. Former Census Bureau Dir. Bruce Chapman, appointed by President Ronald Reagan, told Ross adding citizenship Q to #2020census “would make existing data on citizenship more accurate,” according to Ross’s notes of March 15 phone call
8. In memo to Commerce Sec. Wilbur Ross about impact of adding citizenship Q to #2020census (“Alternative B”), Census Bureau’s chief scientist, acting director & other officials cite $27.5 million as “conservative estimate” of cost Q’s impact on level of noncitizen participation
11. UPDATE from @CommerceGov spokesperson on email about census citizenship question from Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach to Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross via statement to @NPR👇— more here: n.pr/2JtMfoF
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
NEW: The Trump administration must release more internal documents for #2020census citizenship question lawsuits that @TheJusticeDept attorneys had withheld because of deliberative process privilege, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman orders.👇
2. From Judge Furman’s opinion: These documents about #2020census citizenship Q “are not protected by the deliberative process privilege because they merely ‘reflect deliberations about what “message” should be delivered to the public about an already-decided policy decision.’ “
NEW: Trump administration is preparing to ask Supreme Court to block #2020census citizenship question lawsuit deposition of @TheJusticeDept official John Gore
AND
judge on 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has temporarily blocked deposition of @SecretaryRoss for lawsuits 👇
Over past 3+ months, I've read 12,000+ pages of internal docs the Trump admin has released for #2020census citizenship question lawsuits. I've been reporting on how @SecretaryRoss' explanation of how this Q ended up on census has suffered blow after blow w each document dump 👇
@SecretaryRoss 2. Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross oversees the census. He's testified in Congress that Justice Department initiated citizenship Q request in Dec 2017 & he was "responding solely" to that. In March, he announced he approved adding question to forms every US household has to answer
@SecretaryRoss 3. After the announcement, I was having trouble keeping up w all the lawsuits that started popping up. Right now, more than 2 dozen states/cities, plus other groups, are suing the Trump admin in 6 lawsuits around the country. These lawsuits required the release of internal docs.
CONFIRMED: @TheJusticeDept initially "did not want to raise" citizenship Q request for #2020census when approached by @CommerceGov beginning in May 2017 "given the difficulties Justice was encountering in the press at the time (the whole Comey matter)" 👇
@TheJusticeDept@AGSteveMarshall@RepMoBrooks 14. Judge Furman is ordering the release of 3 of the 17 documents in question -- Bates No. 2458, 3984, 9834 -- by Monday, Sept. 17.