Adam Klasfeld Profile picture
Sep 25, 2018 58 tweets 10 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
Pre-dawn rise to cover today’s #UNGA speeches for the start of general debate.

By tradition, Brazil’s up first. Then, it’s Trump followed by Ecuador’s Lenin Moreno, Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and a dozen other speakers in today’s morning session.

More to come.
ICYMI, yesterday: My UNGA preview coverage, recapping what transpired since general debate last year.…
Criminal probes linked to first four heads-of-state #UNGA speakers.

Brazil’s 🇧🇷Temer: graft charges
USA’s 🇺🇸Trump: allies convicted in Russia probe
Ecuador’s 🇪🇨Moreno: arrest warrant on predecessor Correa
Turkey’s 🇹🇷Erdogan: dogged by corruption probe for nearly 5 years
Diplomats milling about in anticipation of the first day of UNGA general debate, as reporters, photographers and videographers look on from above.
UN leaders take the podium: Secretary General @AntonioGuterres and @UN_PGA María Fernanda Espinosa Garcés.

Diplomats mostly standing and walking in the hall.
After a moment of silence for Kofi Annan, Guterres begins his speech on the theme of "trust deficit disorder."

"Within countries, people are losing faith in the political establishment... Populism is on the march."
Guterres: "Universal values are being eroded. Democratic values are under siege."

"Multilateralism is under fire precisely when we need it most," he said.

Guterres added that "we are moving toward a multipolar world," but that won't necessarily solve problems.
After warning of burgeoning authoritarianism, Guterres said: "We need to move ahead based on facts not fear, on reason, not illusion."
Calling climate change an "existential threat," Guterres pushes for dramatic action within two years.

"We must guarantee the implementation of the Paris agreement... but its targets, which represent the bare minimum... are far from being met."
Guterres speech ends. @UN_PGA now opens general debate with a speech.

"Welcome to the only place where a meeting of this kind is possible," Garces says.
Garcés speaks about violence against women, implementing the global compact on migration, and combating climate change and pollution.

She pivots to protection of people with disabilities, whom she calls the "planet's largest minority."
Garcés ends her speech with a tribute to Eleanor Roosevelt and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. She recommends 15 minute speeches. Trump clocked in at three times the recommended floor time last year.…
By tradition, Brazil is up first with president Michel Temer, who recently spoke of the graft charges against him to the Associated Press.…
Temer talks about defending the "integrity of the order."
Temer bemoans a growing tide of "Isolationism, intolerance, and unilateralism."

"Isolation may even give one a false sense of security at first," he said. "Protectionism may even sound productive."

He talks about promoting dialogue and solidarity.
Temer is talking about a "large scale migration wave" in Latin America, particularly from Venezuela, where he notes more than 1 million have fled. He speaks of welcoming these migrants.
Temer talks about being the first leader to sign a treaty to abolish nuclear weapons last year. More on that.…
* "productive" should be "seductive"

Regret the typo
Brazil's Temer steps down. Trump is up next.
There may be a shakeup in the schedule. There is a ramp before the podium, because Ecuadorean President Lenin Moreno - who uses a wheelchair - is now in the number two speaking spot.
Moreno waxes philosophical for his first line: "Everything in life is cause and effect, and every effect implies a cause."
Moreno's florid speech is less a list of global challenges, international crises and issues than it is an ode to the imagination. "Someone asked me once what gave rise to this thinking? Perhaps I was born and grew up in the Amazon region. The lungs of the planet," he says.
Turning to a specific issue, Moreno criticizes the pharmaceutical industry's effect on global health in pursuit of profit.

Context: NYT reported that Ecuador buckled to US pressure from formula makers to drop breast-feeding resolution.…
"As you can see, I get around in a wheelchair," Moreno says. "Is that bad? I don't know."

"From this wheelchair, I see from the eyes of the heart," he adds later.
Reminder: Earlier this morning, the President of the General Assembly, Ecuadorean diplomat Garcés, spoke about her goal of protecting the rights of people with disabilities.
Note: I covered #UNGA last year, and this is an uncommonly poetic, personal and passionate speech, filled more with first-person reflections and philosophizing than the issues on the head of state's agenda.
Moreno slams how "this country" - the United States - continues its "blockade of ... an almost defenseless country," Cuba, in light of its principles of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
After quoting Thomas Jefferson on the Declaration of Independence, Moreno invokes Jose Martí on migration from Venezuela.
Moreno praises @UN_PGA Garcés on becoming the first Latin American woman in her position.
* This tweet was unclear. Clarification: Moreno quoted Martí on migration in general, in a section of his speech detailing the Venezuelan migration crisis.
Moreno finishes his speech. Is Trump here yet? We’ll see.
Trump’s next
Trump steps to the podium, and his speech begins.

"One year ago, I spoke before you in this auditorium for the first time," Trump says, boasting about allegedly accomplishing more in two years than almost any administration.

(Raucous laughter)
"I wasn't expecting that reaction," Trump adds, referring to the laughter.
Lashing out at "global governance," Trump talks about respect for U.S. "national sovereignty," before pivoting to his meeting with Kim Jong Un.
"I'd like to thank Chairman Kim for his courage and the steps he has taken," Trump says.
"I am pleased to report that the bloodthirsty killers known as ISIS have been driven out of Iraq and Syria," Trump says, denouncing what he calls "radical Islamic terrorism."

Pivots to Syrian civil war and then lays into Iran.
"The Iran deal was a windfall for Iran's leaders," Trump says, lashing out at agreement.

Trump talks about reimposing sanctions in November and promises "more will follow."
Trump defends moving U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, blasting warnings of what he calls "so-called experts."

Then, he pivots to trade, where he says U.S. is "systematically renegotiating broken and bad trade deals."
Trump rips into the Human Rights Council and the International Criminal Court.

"As far as America is concerned," Trump says, the ICC has "no jurisdiction" and "no authority."

"We will never surrender American sovereignty to an unelected, unaccountable bureaucracy," he added.
As every other country and diplomat talks about climate change, Trump trumpet's so-called "clean coal" and claims America is getting ripped off by other countries on oil.

"Not good," he adds.
“Above all, we love our country,” he says.

He talks about the “heart of a patriot” inside people of every nation.

Note: WaPo reported Trump’s archnationalist advisor Stephen Miller wrote this speech.
“Together, let us choose a future of patriotism and pride,” Trump continues.

“Thank you, God bless you and god bless the nations of the world,” Trump concludes.

Applause. Trump steps down from the dais.
Experiment with dramatic shifts in tone:

The UN makes transcripts of all speeches public. Read Ecuador’s Moreno’s speech, then Trump’s that immediately followed.

Then report the whiplash of that experience back to me.
The hall largely empties of press and diplomats. The Trump show is over and the Erdogan show is scheduled to begin.
Erdogan steps to the dais and begins his speech.

“We are holding this meeting on the 100th anniversary of the end of the first World War,” he says, speaking of the UN’s genesis from WWII.
Erdogan critiques the permanent five nation structure of the UN Security Council, lamenting veto power for stagnation of Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

“Even if the entire world turns its back, Erdogan says, Turkey will support the side of the “oppressed Palestinians.”
“When we say the ‘world is greater than five,’” Erdogan says that Turkey is becoming the “conscience of the entire human race.”
Erdogan, who has been trailed by a corruption scandal linked to tens of millions in bribes to his top ministers, blasts income inequality and the power of the wealthiest 62 people in the world.
Turkey took in 4 million refugees, he continues, in a portion of the speech on Syrian refugees and humanitarian aid.
Erdogan cites Alliance of Civilizations as an example of country’s humanitarian. The organization was accused of muzzling a press event at the UN.

Turkey leads the world in jailing journalists.…
* humanitarianism.

Pivots to portion of his speech on the July 2016 coup attempt, blaming it on what he calls FETO, Turkey’s acronym for Fethullahist Terrorist Organization.
Erdogan demands extradition of Gulenists, says price for not doing so will be “quite hefty.”
Erdogan's speech ended some time ago.

Service advisory: Left the #UNGA hall, and I'm working on an update to this developing story.…
Mentioned in Trump's #UNGA speech, by the numbers:

Russia: 0
Climate change: 0
Rohingya / Myanmar: 0
multilateralism: 0
plunder: 2
blood (-y; -thirsty): 2
global (pejoritive): 4
illegal immigration: 2
national interest: 2
terror (-ism, -ists): 6
patriot (-ism): 4
sovereignty: 6
Leaving the UN for the day now, I see a Turkish flag hanging day of Erdogan’s speech at the construction site of the future consulate.
Correction: Trump did mention Russia in one brief passage, to slam Germany, who he said was too reliant on its oil.

(An odd critique, given the fact that Germany is a world leader in renewable energy.)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Adam Klasfeld

Adam Klasfeld Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @KlasfeldReports

Oct 9, 2018
Second Circuit REJECTS petition to stay Wilbur Ross's deposition in the #2020Census case, but allows for a 48-hour stay for a SCOTUS appeal.

All eyes on Kavanaugh, who could spare a Trump cabinet member from the hot seat in a case affecting U.S. political power for a decade.
NOTE: A three-judge panel of bipartisan appointees - USCJ Walker (H.W. Bush), USCJ Lohier (Obama) and USDJ Pauley (Clinton) - unanimously rejected the stay the DOJ wanted in a summary order.

We'll learn w/in two days whether post-Kavanaugh SCOTUS divides along partisan lines.
This is an important one to watch.

* Depositions of presidential cabinet members are rare.
* Ross will face questions about false testimony to Congress about why he added the citizenship question. (Cited in "bad faith" quote here)
* Census apportions political power for 10 years
Read 4 tweets
Oct 8, 2018
This chart from the @IPCC_CH climate report is particularly chilling.

Look at our current warming rate: Without dramatic action, scientists predict we hit 1.5 degrees by 2040.

My summary on @CourthouseNews.…
U.N. Secretary-General @AntonioGuterres on the half-degree difference between 1.5- and 2-degree goal.

* Heat waves for tens of millions.
* Extinctions
* Water scarcity
* 10x more Arctic ice free summers
* "Total wipe-out of the world's coral reefs."
Major obstacles from right-wing leaders of two of the world's biggest polluters:

* The US, the 2nd biggest CO2-spewer in 2017, pulling out of the Paris under Trump (effective 2020, per treaty's terms)

* If Brazil, 7th largest, elects Bolsonaro, he will likely withdraw.
Read 5 tweets
Oct 5, 2018
Looks like @TheDemocrats successfully served the GRU in their racketeering suit...
The Russian Federation also got served.

Though both have a receipt date for much earlier, the docket entries appeared for the first time this morning.

When serving the Russian government and intelligence service with racketeering allegations, the clear choice is @FedEx.
Read 4 tweets
Oct 4, 2018
You know who else pined for a thousand years of rule?
I hesitated about posting this tweet because it’s folks shouldn’t be flippant about these historical analogies.

But that also means not letting rhetoric and slogans like this pass without mention.
Either by ignorance, by design, or a combination of the two, Trump keeps echoing the darkest rhetoric and slogans of early 20th century - to the point where we’re collectively desensitized to them.

“America First.” “Enemy of the people.” And now, “1,000 years” rule.
Read 4 tweets
Oct 3, 2018
In the courtroom right now to watch this challenge to the presidential alert system. More to come.
Lead plaintiff, reporter J.B. Nicholas, has had some success with pro se lawsuits in the past.

An ex-researcher for star attorney Ron Kuby, Nicholas was behind a Second Circuit decision letting prisoners unionize and another on NYPD press creds.…
The motion to block today’s test of the presidential alert system was denied, and the test alert will be sent out this afternoon.

More to come later.
Read 5 tweets
Sep 30, 2018
BREAKING: A federal judge denies @CommerceGov's request to stay @SecretaryRoss's deposition in the #2020census case, pending their appeal to the Supreme Court.

Judge Furman calls the government's application "particularly frivolous - if not outrageous."

Scorching ruling.
Note: As the ruling states, the Second Circuit placed an administrative stay on Ross‘s deposition pending their review of that appeal. The government lost a recent appeal involving a DOJ official.

If they lose again, Judge Furman emphasizes, he won’t wait for SCOTUS to weigh in.
NEW: In back-to-back defeats, @CommerceGov loses bid to avoid a trial by resolving the lawsuit on summary judgment.

“The court remains firmly convinced that a trial will be necessary to resolve the claims of this case,” Furman wrote.
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!


0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy


3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!