1/ The more I think about it, the more the way 🇪🇺 has manoeuvred 🇬🇧 on #Brexit transition is masterful.
2/ In the immediate aftermath of the referendum, debate in 🇬🇧 revolved around WHEN #Article50 would be triggered, not consequences of doing so. 🇪🇺 could live with 🇬🇧 triggering in March 2017, as that gets 🇬🇧 out before EP 🗳 2019.
3/ Having triggered, 🇬🇧 wasted time with an early election, and then by time May made her Florence speech in September, even she realised time was short. Hence transition.
4/ But both 🇬🇧 and 🇪🇺 want to avoid a transition into transition and a transition out of transition. So 🇬🇧 had to quickly conceed transition needs to look as much like being in 🇪🇺 as possible.
5/ Again there was an alignment of convenience on timing - May's "around two years" became "by the end of December 2020", lining up transition end with 🇪🇺 budget financial perspectives.
6/ Then it has taken from December's summit until today's release of the transition guidelines for everyone to really realise what transition is going to mean for 🇬🇧: it makes itself a vassal state. Meanwhile the 🇪🇺-27 stand united on the issue.
7/ Plus this is not even the 🇳🇴 option on offer in transition - it is worse than that for 🇬🇧 - it has no representation *whatsoever* in *anything* in 🇪🇺 for at least 21 months.
8/ But what can the 🇬🇧 do now?
9/ Walk away from talks? But then we're back at No Deal Brexit, which even Davis and May seem to have realised is a catastrophe. That threat is not serious. Walk out now, with 14 months of Article 50 to go, and that'll cause panic.
10/ Go through with transition? To do so on these terms puts 🇬🇧 in a remarkably weak position vis à vis 🇪🇺. Surely unacceptable to Tories. 🇪🇺 gets what it wants if 🇬🇧 tries this.
11/ Or attempt some other solution - either grovel to rest of 🇪🇺 to extend #Article50 instead, as it is less painful? Or withdraw the Article 50 notification? These options are also 😡 for Tories.
13/ 🇬🇧 has been manoeuvred into a position where it has to choose *very soon* on transition, all options are tricky, and forcing this sort of choice now, rather than in the autumn is a very good call by 🇪🇺. #Brexit is about to get even more 🔥 /ends
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Prerequisites for this:
- someone ousts May in a Tory leadership election in Sept/Oct
- Govt majority lost, meaning a new GE in Oct/Nov 2018
(both of these are of course open to question - but bear with me!)
2/8
How do the Tories and Labour approach #Brexit in such a General Election campaign?
One presumes that the Tories (with 75% of their membership pro-Brexit) aim for a hard Brexit, something akin to the Chequers deal (or harder). They'd NOT want a #peoplesvote
3/8
This thread examines some of the aspects of extending Article 50 (or not)
1/12
First some background - I have an older blog post here about why extending the Article 50 period would be a good idea: jonworth.eu/transition-per…
And the relevant part of Article 50 is shown here - unanimous agreement of EU-27 needed to extend
2/12
Extending the Article 50 period is not something either side really wants.
BUT No Deal #Brexit is the thing both sides should absolutely fear, especially 🇬🇧 but even the 🇪🇺, whose Member States (especially 🇮🇪) would take a major GDP hit.
But let's just say for a minute that, spurred on by national sandwich sentiment post a No Deal Brexit, the UK did want to make itself more self-sustaining in its food production, what could it do?
2/15
First some stats: Defra has useful stats on UK food import dependency here: gov.uk/government/sta…
The first Excel table shows how import dependency for food has been growing (the UK now imports 40% of its food), and the second Excel download lists value by food type.
Most charming & amusing Russian 🇷🇺 experience to date here in Ulan-Ude...
When planning this trip people asked me: do you speak Russian? Answer: no. But I am armed with Yandex Translate. It has a RU-EN offline dictionary, and can speak it all too: itunes.apple.com/us/app/yandex-…
1/7
You can do pretty complex things with Yandex.
But trying to book a bus 🚌 ticket 🎟 online from Irkutsk to Bratsk was a step too far.
Irkutsk = Иркутск
Bratsk = Братск
is easy enough.
Entering names, gender etc., sure.
But nationality?
2/7
What is my nationality?
England = Англия
Great Britain = Великобритания
UK? = Объединенное королевство великой Британии и северной Ирландии
None in the list...
Enter a confused but helpful hotel receptionist.
3/7
Something about this #Seehofer "resignation" does not add up.
A thread.
1/9
Merkel went to Brussels and got a framework for a deal on refugees, the sort of thing that Seehofer was pushing for. A bit thin on the details, but Merkel did not return empty handed.
2/9
The normal CSU reaction to this would have been to have claimed a minor victory, to show how Bavaria's interests were being taken seriously, and move on somewhat.
3/9