Ady Barkan Profile picture
Dec 30, 2017 12 tweets 6 min read
Yesterday, I linked to @CharlesPPierce's piece arguing that @realDonaldTrump is exhibiting serious cognitive decline. I said he has dementia. I invited you to share your stories of loved ones with similar problems, & hundreds of you did, movingly.
But some of you also pushed back, arguing that it was irresponsible of me to make that armchair diagnosis, because it stigmatizes people with mental illness. It's an important critique, on a crucial question in American politics, so let's talk about it now. #CripTheVote
Last year, disability rights organizers @SFdirewolf @AndrewPulrang & @GreggBeratan created the hashtag #CripTheVote to mobilize disabled voters and talk about disability issues. So we should that hashtag here.…
Alice, Andrew, Gregg and other activists have been living with, thinking about, and working on these issues for far longer than I have. So I approach this conversation with gratitude for their leadership and perspective & with humility and a willingness to be convinced.
I will lay out my perspective here, and then I am very eager to hear from disability rights advocates, health professionals, ethicists, etc. (I've only been thinking about these particular questions for 24 hours, so please read my thoughts with a bunch of salt.) #CripTheVote
There has been a lot of discussion about the president's mental health this year. Let me try to summarize & orient.

I see a number of questions:
1.What is Trump’s mental health status?
2.Who has the right and/or obligation to ask this question publicly?
3.Is it important? Why?
On one end of the spectrum is @duty2warn, an association of mental health professionals advocating Trump be removed under the 25th Amendment as psychologically unfit. Obviously they believe we should be asking/answering this question, because Trump is a danger to the country.
On the other end are @SFdirewolf @AndrewPulrang & @GreggBeratan. I don't want to mischaracterize their arguments, so I will let them speak for themselves. But, I believe they think that discussing Trump's mental health is some combo of irresponsible, stigmatizing, & unnecessary.
Somewhere near @duty2warn on the spectrum are people like @BandyXLee, who recently published a collection of essays about Trump's mental health.…
Lee argues that she has not violated the American Psychiatric Association's "Goldwater Rule" prohibiting the diagnosis of people without proper examination. It is an "assessment" of the level of danger to the American people, not a "diagnosis" of him.
I find Lee’s distinction a bit precious. I haven’t read the book yet, but the excerpts in the Post suggest to me that, although her book may not have “diagnosed” Trump in the professional sense of the word, it has done so in political/practical terms.…
I think that a good thing. I think @BandyXLee has done a service to the country by moving this conversation forward in a responsible manner.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Ady Barkan

Ady Barkan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @AdyBarkan

Oct 7, 2018
2 years ago today, @rachael_scar and I walked into the neurologist's office. She was carrying 4-month-old Baby Carl on her chest.

We walked out an hour later with my death sentence. ALS would paralyze and then kill me, and there wasn't anything we could to stop it.
How would we persevere? What we do with the short time I had left? How could we find hope in the dark?

These were our personal challenges. But they became questions for the nation a month later when Donald Trump was elected president.
Over the past 24 months, I lost the ability to run, and then even to walk; the ability to cut food, and then even to feed myself; the ability to speak quickly, and soon even to speak at all.

And yet, this journey has been better than I feared. On most days, I am happy.

Read 6 tweets
Oct 3, 2018
Do you want Brett Kavanaugh impacting your life for the next 30 years? If not, you have three days to #CancelKavanaugh.

Here are 5 things you can do. I promise you will be glad you did.

(Please RT to help save our democracy.)
1. Show up at a vigil Wednesday evening.

There are vigils happening all around the country. Find one near you, bring some friends with you, alert your local TV station, and tweet out some photos.
2. Come to Washington DC on Thurs/Friday.

We all saw what a huge impact @AnaMariaArchil2 had, simply by showing up to the Senate and telling her story. She wants you to join her. 9 am in the Hart Senate Office Building.

There are buses from major cities.
Read 6 tweets
Apr 7, 2018
.@WorkingFamilies comms director @joedinkin has a better answer than these data wonks:

Reject issue by issue silos & instead go for meta themes.

70: Trump is enriching the rich and powerful at the aexpense of ordinary Americas. (Trumpcare, tax scam, gov corruption all fit here)
30: Trump is dividing Americans from eachother & we can't let him do it. (Attacks on immigrants&muslims fit here, so do voting rights, mass incarceration, civil rights, lgbtq, metoo. This is actually all a pretty dopy way of framing things but the polling suggests it works.
“These are of course both framed in the negative but I'd also split these to be framed in the positive at least 60% of the time. I think people's feelings abt trump are pretty well baked so actually i'd say these should be mostly framed in the positive with the contrast assumed.”
Read 5 tweets
Jan 29, 2018
Like usual, @realDonaldTrump is attacking smart black people who disagree with him. Today's installment? Saying that Jay Z and @VanJones68 should be grateful to him for low black unemployment rates.

@shawnsebastian has a full rebuttal here. I'll give you the abridged version.
First, Donald Trump gets zero credit for the strong economy. Take a look at these 2 charts. The recovery started 8 years ago (under a Black president).

And it was propelled forward until now because Janet Yellen insisted on pursuing true full employment.

Trump fired Yellen.
Yellen was most successful Fed chair in history. She pushed unemployment down & kept inflation low. But Trump replaced her with a less qualified man because he wanted to make his mark on the Fed.

So, his taking credit for this economy is really rich.…
Read 10 tweets
Jan 13, 2018
Wow look! Full employment makes "unemployable" people very employable. And it has tremendous ability to combat racial inequality.

*This* is why we launched Fed Up. Full employment is the most powerful public policy that exists for improving lives.…
By empowering workers to quit if they want, full employment:
Raises wages,
reduces inequality,
combats racial discrimination,
promotes gender equity,
reduces sexual assaults/harassment,
stabilizes schedules,
facilities unionization,
reduces depression&suicide
Enhances skills.
I know there's no such thing as a panacea, but I think that's a pretty unparalleled list of benefits that come as a result of one policy intervention!

Read 16 tweets
Dec 31, 2017
Some end-of-year thoughts about this moment, this movement, power, race, money, and what we need to do together over the coming 10 months. Please read it and retweet it if it strikes a chord with you. And, white people, *please* open your wallets before midnight tomorrow.
This year has been exhausting. For all of us. The racism & xenophobia has been out of control. To me, as a white person, it has been offensive & shocking. But you know what? Those feelings are negligible compared to what it's felt like to be on the receiving end of the hatred.
One example is the disparity between how @lsarsour and I get treated on Twitter. I have received overwhelming positive support. Linda receives daily waves of hatred, racism, and sexism. And death threats. She needs a security detail to get around her beloved Brooklyn.
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!


0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy


3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!