The conversation went like this. Sarah talked about reality and a dark future. Amy continuously responded with unfailing hope.
The message: we all have the power to change the course of our nation every day.
She painted herself as an exhausted yet somehow tireless change agent.
Sarah pumped the brakes, speaking of ways the administration is taking away our power and keeping it from the already disenfranchised. She reminded us constantly that this predates Trump.
So why is Amy's message dangerous? Isn't it great to be hopeful and forward-looking?
Gretel Katz, my grandmother, was once an illegal immigrant in a country that didn't want her.
In 1938, she fled to Switzerland from Nazi-occupied Austria.
Gretel would have been deported were it not for Paul Grüninger, a man who didn't believe in borders. (More on him shortly)
Gretel was raised in Vienna, a dancer in the ballet at the famed Wiener Staatsoper, the Vienna State Opera house. She was 15 and had recently earned a pension, awarded after 9 years work. It was meant to be her job for life.
Here she is on the right with a Viennese opera singer.
In March of 1938, Hitler decreed Jews could not participate in the arts in Vienna.
On April 23rd, 1938, Gretel was handed a letter after a performance at the Staatsoper, addressed to her father Max.
Yes! That has always amazed me, too. The roast beef story is one of six moments in his tale of survival where the determination of life or death was decided in an instant.
At the work camp Szebnie, Monek was working as a gardener at the villa of one of the SS officers in charge.
Every day while the officer was away, his chef would bake fresh dog biscuits for his German Shepherd. She would leave them out, but the dog had no interest.
One day, Monek approached slowly. The dog wagged its tail. Monek was starving, and he took the biscuits and ate them.
“They were delicious!” he recalls. “I don’t know what was in them, but I can still taste them to this day.”
After a while, the chef grew wise and told the SS officer.
One afternoon, the officer emerged from the villa with his shirtsleeves rolled up, his gun in holster.
Meet Arthur Jones. He denies the Holocaust, calling it an "extortion racket." He says that he stands “shoulder to shoulder, philosophically,” with President Trump.
Arthur is running unopposed for the @GOP nomination for Congress in Illinois's 3rd District.
He's predicted to lose against incumbent @RepLipinski, but let's not rest on our laurels. We know what happens when someone is predicted to lose then we don't go out and vote to be sure.